Australia | Apr 05 2006
Australian banks are digging their own grave by clinging on to their relationships with external mortgage brokers to sell part of their products. That is, in a nutshell, the long held opinion of Merrill Lynch’s team of banking analysts.
The team has been warning for a while now that Australian banks will be experiencing the boomerang coming back at them in the form of margin pressure and fierce competition. They think time has now arrived for the banks to act, or stand tall for the boomerang to hit target.
As we can safely assume management teams at Westpac (WBC) and Commonwealth Bank (CBA), just to name a few, won’t feel like they now all of a sudden have to listen to one stockbroker’s opinion we can probably also safely assume the boomerang is definitely about to hit target.
When exactly? Merrill Lynch believes over the next three years.
How painful will it be? The team has made some calculations to put it all in perspective.
Merrill Lynch estimates mortgages represent circa 23% of the sector’s net interest income. The analysts forecast a 20 basis points decline in the banks’ mortgage margins over the next three years. As the volume of mortgages sold is expected to decline by 10% over the period, it is truly not a beautiful picture that lies ahead. Sufficient for the team to state mortgages now are “the single largest source of projected margin decay” for Australian banks.
So what are the banks doing wrong? They are under-utilising their own branches, the team says. Error number one. Secondly, they should be using their own well known brand names to market their products, instead of allowing others to build up familiar household brand names.
Merrill Lynch uses Virgin Money as an example of how easy new entrants can enter the market these days and take their own piece of the pie. Virgin Money is not the cheapest in the market, it is not even offering what the analysts would acknowledge as “something special”. Because it has a low cost model (telephone and internet instead of a wide reaching network of branches that come at a fixed cost) and it is simply marketing and distributing mortgages funded by Macquarie Bank, it has the ability to build up its own brand, market share and later bite the banks in the bum as its more efficient business model allows for a margin of 60 basis points.
In short: Virgin Money will be able to offer larger discounts than the bank can. Good for the consumer. Not so good for the banks and their shareholders.
And that’s just Virgin. No matter what Richard Branson may believe, Virgin is still only a fly in a market full of spiders. Now imagine if Woolworths (WOW) or David Jones (DJS) would copy the model and enter the market.
Fantasyworld? Merrill Lynch believes both companies are studying on the matter.

