article 3 months old

Sector Mispricing Presents Opportunities

Australia | Apr 06 2006

If asked to name an earnings measure that can be used to value a stock or sector the first to come to the mind of many investors is likely to be the Price/Earnings (P/E) ratio. Looking closely at the ratio, the price portion is easy to calculate as it requires just a quick look at the latest market values.

In contrast, the earnings portion of the equation is always accompanied by a certain amount of risk as if forward earnings forecasts are used (and really, historical earnings are of less use when we want to know if a stock is likely to go up or down in the future) the forecast P/E ratio is only as good as the accuracy of the earnings estimate.

In other words, where there is a greater risk of earnings estimates being achieved the multiple for a stock or sector should be lower than for an alternative with less earnings risk.

With this in mind UBS has attempted to identify sector of the market that are inappropriately priced based on the earnings outlook and the certainty of the earnings estimates.

The broker calculates earnings certainty by measuring the range of analysts’ estimates for stocks within a sector, then comparing this to the historical average for the sector. It performs a similar calculation on the current forward P/E ratio and the historical average, the two then being compared together to identify what it regards as mispricing.

This mispricing can be either a buying opportunity, where there is rising earnings certainty but P/E multiples have not expanded accordingly, or a selling chance given the earnings multiple has increased but earnings estimates remain diverse or uncertain.

Applying this approach to the Australian market reveals two sectors stand out, the broker highlighting in particular the resources sector but also the media sector as offering potential opportunities. The broker’s analysis shows the P/E to earnings certainty ratio for resource stocks is still at a 19% discount to its long-term average, which suggests the sector remains attractive despite the tremendous gains of the past years.

At the other end of the scale, the broker suggests the retail sector is among the more expensive, as earnings certainty has been consistently declining in recent years but there has not been an accompanying fall in P/E ratios.

Similarly, it suggests the Real Estate and Other Materials sectors are also looking more expensive as both have seen earnings risk increase but no improvement in valuations to compensate for the higher risk.

To share this story on social media platforms, click on the symbols below.

Click to view our Glossary of Financial Terms

Australian investors stay informed with FNArena – your trusted source for Australian financial news. We deliver expert analysis, daily updates on the ASX and commodity markets, and deep insights into companies on the ASX200 and ASX300, and beyond. Whether you're seeking a reliable financial newsletter or comprehensive finance news and detailed insights, FNArena offers unmatched coverage of the stock market news that matters. As a leading financial online newspaper, we help you stay ahead in the fast-moving world of Australian finance news.