Australia | Apr 06 2006
In a period of three weeks, six out of the ten equity analysts in the FN Arena universe downgraded OneSteel (OST), including four in the last two days. Recent share price strength was a contributing factor in each case.
This now leaves us with one Buy, seven Hold and one Sell recommendation (or equivalents). SB Citigroup is the Buy, but the analysts have actually been quiet on the subject since February and may yet join the rush. Merrill Lynch (Hold) has also not been spotted lately. UBS downgraded to Reduce from Hold yesterday, while Macquarie, GSJB Were, Deutsche Bank, JP Morgan and Aspect Huntley have all moved from Buy to Hold.
ABN Amro (Hold) stands alone in not having shifted its rating despite publishing a report yesterday, but it’s recommended Hold all year.
Poor old OneSteel must feel a bit put out, as most of the downgrades followed an analyst picnic day on-site in Sydney. Perhaps the sausage sangers were a bit limp.
Apart from share price movements, a common theme was an increase in the cost of scrap metal, along with the general increase in operating costs, such as those any company remotely connected with resources has recently had to endure. A bit of revenue certainty would also be nice, but iron ore prices are tetchy things.
Suffice to say "Hold" in this instance implies a bit of "wait and see" from this level. JP Morgan bucked the trend a little, however, by suggesting in its downgrade two weeks ago that it simply preferred Bluescope (BSL).

