Australia | Apr 07 2006
Aspect Huntley has been playing with the BHP Billiton (BHP) numbers. If it takes a mooted doubling of copper output and tripling of uranium output at Olympic Dam, and then makes the unusual assumption that spot prices for both remain flat for 15 years (in other words ignoring the backwardation), then it would add $10.00 to the analysts’ current valuation of $19.55.
A nice thought, but even Aspect suggests this is an unlikely, albeit interesting, what-if scenario.
Back in the real world, Aspect is suggesting it’s time to look at cashing in on some of BHP’s remarkable gains. The analysts have downgraded to Reduce. This does not mean Sell. On the FN Arena scale of Buy/Hold/Sell Reduce is ascribed a value in between Hold and Sell. Aspect is simply looking at the world from the sensible trader’s point of view – one is supposed to start selling some BHP shares, not all of them.
The Merrill Lynch target price of $35.00, set by resources guru and no doubt current darling of the mining companies, Vicky Binns, is an outlier in consensus terms. UBS ($32.00) is the only other broker from the FN Arena universe that has set a target in excess of yesterday’s close.
The average FN Arena target sits at $28.72, and we closed yesterday at $29.49. Seven out of ten brokers still rate BHP a Buy, which tends to cement the zeitgeist of targets being a bit meaningless when you’ve got commodity prices that just won’t stop.
However, if the simple formula that brokers normally stick to – if the share price exceeds your target you downgrade to Hold (this was certainly good enough for OneSteel (OST) yesterday) – then Aspect Huntley is one advisor that seems justified in its profit-taking call at this point, if the numbers are anything to go by.
FN Arena readers may take note that Credit Suisse has actually upgraded BHP to Outperform this morning with a target price of $35.79. This brings the total of "Buy" recommendations in the FN Arena universe to eight.

