Australia | Apr 18 2006
When equity markets are at record levels hype can often take the place of substance, as survivors of the internet bubble in the 1990s and those enjoying the current resources boom will attest.
Often the hype means stocks can become overpriced, particularly new offerings to the market where demand was heavy and applications were scaled-back, leading to buying interest in the stock when it lists on the exchange.
This makes the recent listing of Dyno Nobel (DXL) more interesting than the normal float, as the initial public offering of the stock was strongly sought after given the company’s leading position in the explosives market in the US.
Despite heavy scaling back of applications and a decent premium on listing, both Intersuisse and Aspect Huntley have suggested investors could do better by investing in the company’s main competitor in the Australian market, Orica (ORI).
Interestingly, even though Intersuisse, being a local equity broker of rather limited size, uses Aspect Huntley research to complement its own inhouse analysis, both equity research specialists hold a different investment opinion on Dyno Nobel shares, even though it is not that different.
Intersuisse rates the stock as Accumulate closer to $2.00 but prefers Orica at current share price levels, while Aspect Huntley has a straight Sell rating, suggesting at current prices the FY07 P/E multiple of 22x is too much to pay. Also, Aspect Huntley points out Dyno Nobel comes a poor second in terms of margins in Australia at around 9% compared to more than 20% for Orica.
Intersuisse also notes management needs time to settle into their roles, which again favours Orica in the medium-term, as does the relative balance sheet strength of the two companies. As the broker notes, Dyno Nobel has far higher gearing levels than does Orica, which is more of a concern given the company’s main operational focus is the US, whereas Orica has a more diversified range of operations.
Another issue investors need to consider stems from the company’s announcement last week that due to higher capital costs it was not proceeding with the expansion of operations at Moura as had been indicated in the prospectus.
The announcement so soon after listing was a surprise to the market in Intersuisse’s view, as this was a potential short-term growth option for the company. While management indicated it is exploring alternatives, these are unlikely to impact on earnings in the next year or two and so make a more favourable opinion on the stock in relation to Orica even more difficult to justify.
One potential positive for Dyno Nobel noted by Intersuisse is the stock is likely to enter the S&P/ASX100 Index in the near future, so given applications were scaled-back in the IPO process there could be some index related buying support when this occurs.
Market opinion generally is positive towards Orica at current levels, the FN Arena database showing the stock is rated as Buy by four brokers and equity researchers, compared to five Hold ratings and one Accumulate recommendation.
Target prices on the stock range as high as $27.00, which compares to a current market price of around $24.00. Dyno Nobel is currently trading at around $2.55, compared to a final IPO offer price of $2.37.

