Australia | Apr 20 2006
As market conditions change the returns generated by different investment styles also change, with current conditions a good reflection of this as the run in the resources sector favours momentum players over value investors.
Regardless of whatever approach is currently in favour the market always offers some value opportunities, with ABN Amro applying such an approach to identify what it suggests are some attractive value plays at current levels.
In setting its criteria for what represents value the broker has used a number of measures, including the market consensus for forecast yield and the reliability of this yield, the valuation of the stock based on its current P/E compared to its historical average P/E and the level of risk attached to consensus earnings estimates.
The broker then rates each stock on each measure, the highest scoring representing the better value plays. Using such an approach allowed the broker to identify what it suggests are the ten best value plays among the stocks that make up the ASX200 index.
Included in the Top-10 list are APN News & Media (APN), Coca-Cola Amatil (CCL), Ridley Corporation (RIC), Repco Corporation (RCL), Foster’s Group (FGL), Corporate Express (CXP), Amcor (AMC), WA Newspapers (WAN), John Fairfax Holdings (FXJ) and Wesfarmers (WES).
Among these stocks, the broker currently has Buy ratings on APN News & Media and Foster’s, the remaining stocks all scoring Hold ratings.
Comparing these ratings to the broader market view as represented by the FN Arena database of leading stockbrokers and equity researchers, the broker is more positive towards APN than most as the database shows the stock is rated Buy two times compared to eight Hold ratings. The broker’s target price of $5.40 is also slightly above the consensus target of $5.23.
It is a similar story with Foster’s, the FN Arena database showing the stock receives two Buy ratings, compared to seven Hold recommendations and one Sell rating. ABN’s $6.50 target is also higher than consensus, which stands at about $6.10.
While ABN’s Hold ratings on the remaining stocks are broadly in line with the consensus ratings recorded in the FN Arena database, its target prices for Repco, Corporate Express, Amcor and John Fairfax are below the consensus target prices. The differences are most noticeable in Repco and Corporate Express, where the broker’s targets of $2.16 and $5.75 compare to consensus targets of $2.55 and $6.04 respectively.

