Australia | May 03 2006
By Rudi Filapek-Vandyck
Not many equity experts would necessarily agree, but Morgan Stanley analyst Craig Campbell thinks there is still a trading opportunity in Excel Coal (EXL).
The FN Arena database of ten leading equity experts in Australia, which doesn’t include Morgan Stanley, shows two positive ratings only (Aspect Huntley and Merrill Lynch) against six Neutral recommendations.
Morgan Stanley’s Campbell, however, believes an Overweight recommendation still applies for the NSW coal miner, citing a favourable long term outlook for the company.
Apart from the near term scheduled ramp up of Excel’s Millennium project, Campbell believes the pending thermal coal price settlement in Asia is likely to provide the share price with a boost. Morgan Stanley anticipates a price settlement of US$53.00/t while adding the forecast figure carries upside risk.
The broker notes spot markets are currently trading at US$53.33/t from Newcastle, compared to the current contract price of US$53.00/t.
Management of Excell has said earlier it too expects the contract thermal coal price negotiations to result in a price settlement at US$50/t or more.
Morgan Stanley has raised its EPS forecasts hot on the heels of Excel Coal’s recently released March quarter production report – the same one that oddly enough inspired several others to scale back to Neutral.
The company is now expected to report a FY07 EPS of $1.00 versus $0.96 previously, while FY08’s figure went up to $1.45 from $1.38. EPS forecast for FY06 remains $0.55.
The broker sees its view supported by management at Coal & Allied (CNA), 76% owned by Rio Tinto (RIO), who also believes prices for thermal coal are likely to remain high.
According to Thomson One Analytics (12 experts) the median EPS forecast in the market for this year currently stands at $0.48, with expectations ranging from $0.55-$0.43. This implies Morgan Stanley sits on the bullish side of the fence, but not the most bullish.
As far as price targets go, Thomson One’s mean target stands at $8.03 with the market range from $9.45 to $6.40.
Excel Coal shares are currently trading around $8.20.
Morgan Stanley has a DCF valuation for Excel Coal of $9.45 per share, which happens to be also the broker’s price target.

