Australia | May 12 2006
By Rudi Filapek-Vandyck
National Australia Bank’s (NAB) latest result may have met, or even exceeded, analyst expectations, but it is the valuation of NAB shares that "remains an issue". On top of this, some securities specialists like the banking team at Merrill Lynch, point out that the bank’s strategy execution is not without risk "particularly given a soft revenue picture domestically".
The good news is management remains on track to successfully achieve a turnaround from darker days and most analysts have increased their earnings forecasts for the near term.
There are some weak points, however, with Merrill Lynch zooming in on NAB’s domestic retail/SME banking which the broker describes as "disappointing". A two percent revenue growth relative to the second half of last year on lending growth of seven percent was not really what the banking analysts were looking for to be anywhere near excited.
In the broker’s view, NAB’s largest division will need to fire up a bit in the second half, especially since the analysts foresee headwinds for the institutional banking operations. NAB will also have to compensate the loss of income due to recent divestments that represent circa three percent of group earnings.
Credit Suisse’s banking team bluntly comments the result was not good enough to support NAB’s current valuation. The turnaround is not expected to come into full effect until FY08.
JP Morgan’s Brian Johnson has increased earnings forecasts as well, while keeping his Underweight recommendation intact. As mentioned earlier, it’s a valuation thing.
UBS has now scaled back its sector rating to Neutral, stating only ANZ (ANZ) managed to report an above market consensus result and that simply is not enough in light of the recent strong re-rating for the sector.
UBS analysts join the chorus in stating NAB management appears to be doing a great job, but it’s the lofty valuation of NAB shares that prevents them from changing the current Neutral recommendation.
The stand out among the leading local brokerages is ABN Amro who clearly has taken a positive view on matters, seeing room for future surprises and raising its price target to $41.22.
ABN Amro and Deutsche Bank are the only ones who rate National a Buy in the FN Arena universe.

