Australia | May 19 2006
By Greg Peel
Yesterday FN Arena brought news that Australasian brewer and beverages company Lion Nathan’s (LNN) CEO refused to comment on speculation that the company would bid for Independent Distillers, New Zealand’s biggest supplier of vodka lolly-water. Realistically, the market is really hoping it will.
However, it’s now hard to see that happening for two reasons: firstly, at potentially A$1.1bn it is a big ask and secondly, Lion Nathan has just announced capital initiatives which will see a 30c special dividend, an increased dividend payout ratio from 70% to 80%, and a 5% capital buyback. This is hardly a move expected of a company looking for big acquisitions.
And that’s where Lion’s problem lies, as far as the broking community is concerned. The result was within expectations, and although New Zealand was really quite poor the good news was that Aussie beer sales have been strong. The company has plenty of cash. What it doesn’t have is growth prospects.
Lion has made several tilts at popular Australian boutique brewer, Cooper’s, but each time has been stymied by a closely held register of family and friends. After the last recent effort Lion may well have given up for good. What then can the company buy? Not much it seems.
Lion Nathan is poorly rated in the FN Arena database with 6 Holds and 3 Sells. Credit Suisse downgraded the stock to Hold before result and SB Citigroup after, thus wiping out the last Buys. Without an acquisition to provide growth, the brokers can’t see much in the way of prospects for the share price, other than it will be underpinned by the capital initiatives. Exacerbating the situation is an inevitable increase in raw material costs.
There are a couple of slight positives, nevertheless. As beer sales do not abate in times of crisis, Lion Nathan is considered a defensive stock. So if everyone’s bailing out of resources the beer sector is one place to turn. The other news is that investment uber-celebrity Warren Buffet has been sniffing around Japan, and rumour has it that Kirin Brewery may be in his sights. Kirin owns 46% of Lion Nathan.
The brokers have set a database average target price of $8.10 for Lion Nathan, which yesterday closed at $8.41.

