Australia | May 19 2006
By Greg Peel
One thing all bank analysts will tell you is that the transition phase to AIFRS accounting has been a nightmare for the sector. Well at least a nightmare for the analysts who found bank comparability almost impossible this season due to the vagaries of the switching process.
Nevertheless, the general consensus has been that National Australia Bank (NAB), while looking better, still faces stiff competition and earnings growth prospects are not that flash, particularly when compared to Westpac (WBC) and ANZ (ANZ) (although it must be said that order of selection varies from broker to broker).
Presently the FN Arena database shows nine brokers split between 1 Buy, 6 Holds and 2 Sells. The one Buy comes from the ABN Amro analysts who have decided, having waded through the minefield that is AIFRS, that NAB actually comes out looking the best.
A superior earnings profile, is ABN’s call, with flexibility on expenses and the possibility of strong capital management in FY07-08. ANZ would have rated higher, but its share price appreciation has relegated it to second place.
Merrill Lynch is not as much of a fan, having today increased its expectations of ongoing costs for NAB. The analysts do note NAB’s improved efficiencies, and the success of its UK business, but wonders how the bank will deliver in Australia. Which competitor will it take market share from?

