article 3 months old

CBA’s New Flat Fee Accounts Not Sufficient To Address Market Share Issues

Australia | May 25 2006

By Chris Shaw (Tokyo)

Commonwealth Bank (CBA) has announced two new "flat fee" accounts aimed at the retail market in a move that JP Morgan points out was well flagged to the market, but in the view of both UBS and Merrill Lynch is unlikely to be enough to address the bank’s market share issues.

The key according to UBS, which rates the stock as Neutral 1 with a price target of $43.50, is whether enough customers take up the new accounts to reverse the trend of lost deposits. It its view no is the answer, as it suggests the bank needs to make further investments to improve its staff and increase customer satisfaction.

The broker also suggests work needs to be done to improve the premium financial services business, as currently it is only growing at about 25% of the rate of the retail operations. Similarly, the market share for business banking is now 13%, down from 20% in 1996.

On the other hand, Merrill Lynch takes the view the new products will go some way to addressing the customer service and market share position, particularly as it shows competitors the largest player in the deposit market is now ready to compete more aggressively for business. It also shows the bank has realised it needs to simplify its account and fee structure, so the move is positive in that regard in the broker’s view.

Having said that, Merrills sees the potential for management’s estimated $10-15m impact from the new accounts to grow to $50-$100m over time, though an increase in volumes could partially offset this.

As a result, it suggests management’s target of above market EPS growth over the next three years will be difficult to achieve. The broker rates the stock as Sell and considers Commonwealth to be the least attractive bank among the majors, behind Westpac (WBC), St George (SGB), ANZ Banking Group (ANZ) and National Australia Bank (NAB).

UBS agrees the earnings impact could be more pronounced, while also calculating there is a possible earnings hole of as much as $157m to come after the completion of the "Which New Bank?" program thanks to an increase in project spending.

The broker’s earnings estimates for the bank are slightly below market consensus, as it is forecasting EPS in FY06 of $2.96 and in FY07 of $3.20, compared to consensus numbers of $3.01 and $3.27.

In contrast, JP Morgan has retained its Overweight rating on the stock as it sees the move as the turning point in the bank’s strategy. The broker suggests the new CEO, Ralph Norris, is now clearly moving to address the issue of poor distribution performance by becoming more aggressive in the pricing of products relative to its competitors.

The FN Arena database shows CBA is rated as Buy twice and Sell twice, while six brokers and equity researchers rate the stock as Hold.

The average target price is $43.77, compared to a last closing price of $44.21.

To share this story on social media platforms, click on the symbols below.

Click to view our Glossary of Financial Terms

Australian investors stay informed with FNArena – your trusted source for Australian financial news. We deliver expert analysis, daily updates on the ASX and commodity markets, and deep insights into companies on the ASX200 and ASX300, and beyond. Whether you're seeking a reliable financial newsletter or comprehensive finance news and detailed insights, FNArena offers unmatched coverage of the stock market news that matters. As a leading financial online newspaper, we help you stay ahead in the fast-moving world of Australian finance news.