Australia | 11:28 AM
Coles' 1Q27 update and earnings downgrade disappointed the market with management outlining its strategic pathway to arrest the market share declines
- Coles loses sales momentum as Woolworths regains market share
- Pricing and promotional strategy reset to defend competitive position
- Increased price investment raises risks to FY27 earnings
- Analysts debate relative valuations and preference for Coles over Woolworths
By Danielle Ecuyer
The valuation battle between Coles and Woolworths
The tussle between valuation and quality remains a key aspect of how analysts and investors view attractive opportunities in the share market.
Quality can be ascribed a multiplicity of characteristics, including management, earnings track record and resilience, as well as strength of cash flow generation and a company's balance sheet.
The contrast and comparison between Australia’s two major consumer staples companies has yet again brought this tussle into focus.
For those readers with more longstanding memories, traditionally Woolworths Group ((WOW)) has tended to be valued and perceived as the superior, quality operator to Coles Group ((COL)), and thus commanded a premium for its operational (out)performance.
Over the last year or so, analysts have by and large been preferencing Coles over Woolworths, predominantly on valuation grounds, but also because Coles had been taking market share from its nemesis.
The latest quarterly update has challenged that investment thesis, with Coles now facing the prospect of having to invest more aggressively to defend its own market share, while Woolworths has savings available to fund its own price investment and reverse the trend in market share shifting between the two.
For context, this article can be read in conjunction with the recent Woolworths update, https://fnarena.com/2026/11/02/woolworths-valuation-keeps-buy-ratings-away/
Earnings downgrade
Regrettably, Coles' latest quarterly update tripped up not only analysts but also the market, with management offering a disappointing 1Q27 trading update, featuring a sales guidance downgrade and, notably, a loss of market share.
Unsurprisingly, the share price has taken a beating in the aftermath, falling from a pre-announcement high of around $24.60 to $21.26, a circa -13% retracement.
The size of the market punishment broadly aligns with analysts' earnings downgrades for FY27.
Arguably, a fall of this magnitude in a large-cap, typically defensive stock would be seen as unusual, but share markets have become more volatile and instant punishments in response to earnings disappointment no longer treat bellwether large caps more gently than your average small cap wannabe.
Equally, the ASX200 has been experiencing investor crowding into large-cap defensives, with the rise in passive ETF flows contributing too.
Recent market updates by companies directly exposed to consumer spending have generated more warnings and disappointments than otherwise, including from Wesfarmers ((WES)) and JB Hi-Fi ((JBH)).
Coles management pointed out the outlook for supermarket sales had deteriorated, with growth continuing to moderate in October, ahead of the RBA's fifth rate hike in 2026 on November 3, taking it to the highest level in 18-years.
The full story is for FNArena subscribers only. To read the full story plus enjoy a free two-week trial to our service SIGN UP HERE
If you already had your free trial, why not join as a paying subscriber? CLICK HERE