Treasure Chest | Aug 12 2026
This story features COLES GROUP LIMITED, and other companies.
For more info SHARE ANALYSIS: COL
The company is included in ASX20, ASX50, ASX100, ASX200, ASX300 and ALL-ORDS
FNArena's Treasure Chest reports on money making ideas from stockbrokers and other experts. Today's idea is Orora.
By Danielle Ecuyer
Whose Idea Is It?
RBC Capital
The subject:
International beverage-packaging group Orora ((ORA)).

August reporting season is likely to turn into a smorgasbord of hits and misses for investors, with more than just an eye on earnings, but also guidance and market expectations.
In the case of Orora, RBC Capital has been banging the proverbial ‘bearish’ drum in the run up to Thursday’s FY26 result.
Bottom line, RBC expects FY26 EPS to come in -5% below consensus expectations, on an even larger than already flagged and expected disappointment from Saverglass.
More Info
On Thursday (tomorrow), revenue is expected to rise by 4%, meeting consensus, but the real disappointment is expected across several financial metrics on the P&L, including misses of -1% on earnings (EBITDA), -2% for EBIT and -3% for net profit after tax, all versus consensus.
A final 5c dividend per share is also expected.
Long standing Orora shareholders would be aware of the travails of Saverglass, which was acquired in December 2023. Over two years ago, FNArena wrote of the problems with customer de-stocking, which prompted an earnings downgrade in April 2024.
Even back then FNArena wrote “an end to destocking and demand softness remains elusive, and these conditions have persisted longer than management anticipated”.
https://fnarena.com/index.php/2024/04/24/orora-awaiting-the-end-of-destocking/
Roll on to July 2026 and Macquarie noted there had been no updates around Saverglass since April, which, all things being equal, points to unchanged guidance, this analyst surmises.
Macquarie’s earnings (EBIT) forecast is at the low end of the guidance range, while stressing the product mix exposure is adverse, with more champagne/wine and less spirits over time.
There is also a downgrading by customers within those segments, a trend which is likely to continue as cost-of-living pressures persist.
The outlook for the global spirits industry remains “lackluster”, as observed in commentary from the US/European market participants.
Macquarie points the finger at “de-premiumisation”, which results in a forecast decline in Euro earnings (EBIT) of -11% y/y for FY27, on top of an expected -29% decline in 2H26 y/y.
Even after assuming the potential for the Rak plant in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) to restart in 1H27, which represents 15% of Saverglass’ capacity, as well as the re-opening of the Strait of Hormuz, which might offset some of the direct costs, Macquarie lowered EPS forecasts by -4% for FY26, -13% for FY27 and -8% for FY28.
This broker’s target price slipped to $1.55 from $1.90 and the rating was also downgraded to Neutral from Outperform.
Ord Minnett equally slashed earnings forecasts in July on the back of “downbeat” data from the liquor industry. There has been no good news from major end customers like Coles Group ((COL)) and Endeavour Group ((EDV)).
Nielsen showed American spirit volumes fell -7% y/y in the three months to June, while in Europe they fell -3.5% y/y in the three months to the end of May.
EPS forecasts were lowered by -0.8% for FY26, -13.1% for FY27 and -11.7% for FY28. The target price fell to $1.55 from $1.70. An Accumulate rating was retained by Ord Minnett due to what appears a ‘cheap’ valuation.
As Ord Minnett recently explained, risk remains of a sizeable write-down of the value of the Saverglass business, which was purchased for $2.2bn and is now seemingly worth a market value around $850m, even post a -$200m investment in plant upgrades for the Gawler plant, unless there is some improvement in end market demand.
RBC Capital had already slashed earnings forecasts by -20% to -28% at the end of July.
Underlying demand continues to struggle. RBC notes Euro Circana packaging data saw glass volumes decline in the four weeks to June 14, with liquor down by -5.8%, carbonated soft drinks off -2.1%, and non-alcoholic beverages up 0.3%.
In addition, RBC points to the O-I Glass share price, which fell -15% after its 2Q result missed and full year earnings were downgraded. This company has experienced a fall in European earnings of -93%, arising from increased competition, higher energy costs and restructuring issues.
The Rak plant is expected to remain in care and maintenance for longer, while a roll off in European hedges is flagged for 2H27.
Ahead of tomorrow’s release, RBC’s EPS forecasts sit -5% below consensus for FY26 and -24% for FY27, while pointing at the prospect of more downbeat guidance from management.
Cashflow is anticipated to decline by -29% to $204m, below market expectations of $226m, while net leverage is expected to lift to 1.2x.
RBC’s target price was reduced to $1.70 from $1.85 at the July downgrade. The stock is still ascribed a Sector Perform rating.
Despite all the downbeat news, a downtrodden share price and lower valuation can be discounting a lot of bad news.
Even RBC considers the stock is “fairly valued” on a FY27 earnings forecast multiple of 16.4x, accounting for the earnings risks.
A little bit of history
Orora was demerged from Amcor in December 2013.
The shares initially traded at roughly 65c–70c. At $1.53 on 11 August 2026, they have therefore more than doubled in nominal price, approximately a 125% increase using 68c as the starting point.
However, that end-to-end comparison conceals a distinctly uneven journey. The shares performed strongly through much of the first decade and traded above $3 at their peak.
Orora shares have subsequently weakened as operating conditions deteriorated and investors questioned the expensive Saverglass acquisition, leverage and European glass demand.
At $1.53, the shares are roughly half their historical peak and about -26% lower over the past year.
Find out why FNArena subscribers like the service so much: “Your Feedback (Thank You)” – Warning this story contains unashamedly positive feedback on the service provided.
FNArena is proud about its track record and past achievements: Ten Years On
Click to view our Glossary of Financial Terms
CHARTS
For more info SHARE ANALYSIS: COL - COLES GROUP LIMITED
For more info SHARE ANALYSIS: EDV - ENDEAVOUR GROUP LIMITED
For more info SHARE ANALYSIS: ORA - ORORA LIMITED

