Tag Archives: Base Metals and Minerals

article 3 months old

The Overnight Report: Caution

By Greg Peel

The Dow closed down 20 points or 0.1% while the S&P lost 0.3% to 2041 as the Nasdaq fell 0.4%.

Consolidation

On Friday the ASX200 fell 70 points before recovering to a close of down 26, having briefly breached the 4900 mark at the low. Yesterday the index only made to 4910 on a 27 point drop to late morning before recovering to be down 6 at the close.

At the moment it appears the buyers are happy to step in around the 4900 mark. So many times this year we have seen sharp legs down through 4900 very quickly turn into sharp rebounds back again to the safety of the 5000 level. This time we’re actually seeing some consolidation at these familiar lows, which is probably a good thing.

Technical analysts are still calling the index to 5350-5400 as long as the previous lows hold. The last couple of sessions would suggest the lows are holding, barring anything unforeseen. Consolidation in commodity prices is making a supportive contribution, fighting back against bank woes. Other sectors have been largely oscillating up and down of late.

Yesterday the resource sectors held up the market, with energy rising 1.6% and materials 1.5%. Perhaps the interesting point to note is that energy only rose 1.6% when oil prices jumped 5-6% overnight. In the not so distant past, energy was flying around over 3% a day up and down with every little tick up or down in WTI. Similarly, the materials sector rose yesterday despite the iron ore price falling.

We might conclude that the dooming and glooming of analysts in recent weeks -- warning that commodity prices were being artificially supported by short-covering and temporary restocking – is no longer striking fear in the market given commodity price consolidation.

Can there be any more bad news for the banks? Well, they may yet be forced to raise more capital on stricter regulatory requirements, but this is pretty well understood and likely well priced in. The banks were off 0.4% yesterday in a session which saw mixed sector moves. An off-target Wesfarmers ((WES)) led the consumer sectors down a percent and helped balance resource sector gains.

Sitting here above the 4900 level, it appears the local market is looking towards Wall Street and the US earnings season to provide direction just as much as Wall Street is at present. But we must not forget China, which, having been out of the news for a few weeks, is back in this week with a load of March data and the March quarter GDP result.

Positive Sign?

China’s CPI came in at 2.3% annual in March, unchanged from February. Economists had forecast 2.5%, and Beijing’s target is 3%, thus the assumption is the door is still well and truly open for further stimulus.

The bad news is the PPI was down again in a negative run that has now lasted four years. The good news is that the 4.3% annual drop in March is an improvement on the 4.9% drop marked in February. Could there be light at the end of the tunnel? We’ll need to get past the typical distortion Chinese data suffers before, during and after the New Year break before any trend can be confirmed.

And We’re Off

Alcoa’s March quarter result beat on earnings but missed on revenue. The result came out after the closing bell and Alcoa shares are currently down 4.5% in the aftermarket, having closed up 4% before the bell.

While the focus is always on the S&P500’s net earnings result – and it is interesting to note these past couple of sessions have seen analyst forecast actually pulling back from the dour numbers previously forecast – it may yet be revenue growth, or lack thereof, that provides the most impact this season. Alcoa achieved an earnings beat through cost cutting. There is only so far cost cutting can go to improve earnings before revenue potential begins to be affected as well.

What Wall Street wants to see is real earnings growth, which needs to be supported by revenue growth.

It’s early days. Alcoa’s release is only considered to mark the unofficial start of each US result season because it was always the first Dow stock to report. Alcoa is no longer in the Dow, but traditions are hard to shake. We now have to wait until the end of the week before the big banks start reporting, including the actual first Dow stock, JP Morgan Chase. Forecasts are for the banks to have had a shocker, losing a net 20% in earnings from the March quarter 2015.

On Friday night the Dow rallied 150 points before pulling back to close up only 35. Last night the Dow rallied 150 points to close down 20. In each case a jump in the oil price provided initial incentive – the oils are up another couple of percent this morning – but Wall Street has not wanted to go on with it.

Patience is required.

Commodities

West Texas is up US75c at US$40.36/bbl and Brent is up US$1.00 at US$42.85/bbl.

Commodity prices were offered some support from the US dollar last night, which is continuing its gradual decline. The dollar index is down 0.2% at an eight month low 93.98.

The greenback didn’t help aluminium nevertheless, which closed down 1% in London, to mark the only move of any real significance amongst the base metals.

Slightly more significant is a near 5% jump in the iron ore price, which is up by US$2.60 at US$55.90/t.

Gold found some support in the greenback, rising US$19.70 to US$1258.10/oz.

But every silver lining has a cloud. The Aussie is up 0.6% at US$0.7598.

Today

The SPI Overnight closed down one point.

The global economic and local stock calendars are both exceedingly bare today. The only highlight is the release today of the NAB business confidence survey for March.

Rudi will appear via Skype-link on Sky Business this morning, 11.15am, to discuss broker calls.
 

All overnight and intraday prices, average prices, currency conversions and charts for stock indices, currencies, commodities, bonds, VIX and more available in the FNArena Cockpit.  Click here. (Subscribers can access prices in the Cockpit.)

(Readers should note that all commentary, observations, names and calculations are provided for informative and educational purposes only. Investors should always consult with their licensed investment advisor first, before making any decisions. All views expressed are the author's and not by association FNArena's - see disclaimer on the website)

All paying members at FNArena are being reminded they can set an email alert specifically for The Overnight Report. Go to Portfolio and Alerts in the Cockpit and tick the box in front of The Overnight Report. You will receive an email alert every time a new Overnight Report has been published on the website.

Find out why FNArena subscribers like the service so much: "Your Feedback (Thank You)" - Warning this story contains unashamedly positive feedback on the service provided. www.fnarena.com

article 3 months old

Material Matters: 2016 Outlook, Precious & Base Metals, Iron Ore And Steel

-Rebound or re-stocking in China?
-Over the worst for some metals?
-Gold sustainable above US$1,150/oz
-Stubborn copper surplus continues
-Steel disconnect with iron ore

 

By Eva Brocklehurst

Commodities 2016

UBS wonders whether Chinese growth is starting to rebound, or whether the evidence so far is merely of re-stocking after the winter. The broker's economists expect the upcoming March economic data will show the start of a sequential rebound in activity but analysts' channel checks with companies suggest re-stocking is the driver so far.

The most notable change to the broker's commodity price deck so far for 2016 is a 20% reduction in zircon and titanium dioxide feedstock prices, as a result of a breakdown in producer discipline. Iluka Resources ((ILU)) has followed from Rio Tinto ((RIO)) and Tronox and announced a US$100/t reduction to zircon prices.

Credit Suisse believes the worst of the downturn has passed for aluminium, metallurgical coal, zinc, lead and gold. The broker also believe the ferrous sector has improved after China pulled forward infrastructure plans.

The broker increases forecasts for China's steel output, improving its view of iron ore demand as well. Iron ore supply appears tighter this year but large surpluses are still expected from 2017 as supply expansions take place.

Precious Metals

The speed at which a positive gold scenario has played out has surprised Credit Suisse, with the yellow metal briefly cutting through US$1,300/oz amidst exchange traded fund (EFT) purchases and declining mine supply. The broker raises forecasts for gold to average US$1,270/oz in 2016 and US$1,313/oz in 2017.

Support has come through declining real interest rates, a weaker US dollar and safe haven demand. Prices have pulled back from their highs but, nevertheless, Credit Suisse suspects a three-year down trend has reversed. The broker does not believe a return to sub US$1,150/oz is likely or sustainable.

Meanwhile, silver is tracking gold higher, and the broker expects the gold/silver ratio to re-test highs above one standard deviation, given stronger gold fundamentals and a lack of major drivers for silver. International capital flows and a heightened geopolitical risk premium are factors which the broker suspects favour gold over silver.

UBS agrees the same criteria makes holding gold versus other assets a more attractive proposition this year. The broker maintains a gold price forecast of US$1,225/oz for 2016 believing a re-allocation into gold is warranted, although not forecasting a bull run. Australia's gold miners, on average, are generating strong cash flow and have improving balance sheets.

The broker believes gold equities will continue to perform well but investors should still be selective. UBS has a preference in the large cap segment for Evolution Mining ((EVN)) and Regis Resources ((RRL)) over Newcrest Mining ((NCM)) and OceanaGold ((OGC)). In smaller cap stocks the broker is drawn to Beadell Resources ((BDR)) and Alacer Gold ((AQG)).

Base Metals

UBS believes the copper price is vulnerable to some downside, estimating demand growth would need to run at over 5.0% in China to absorb the market surplus. Supply could be tweaked to re-balance the trade, but in this instance the broker observes most operations are still generating cash and cost curves are falling.

In copper UBS prefers Sandfire Resources ((SFR)) over OZ Minerals ((OZL)), given the latter's pending expenditure in Carrapateena.

Credit Suisse has become more bearish on copper, believing copper demand growth in China will fade rather than rebound and copper is likely to remain in surplus this decade unless there are cuts to production.

Nickel is one base metal where much of the industry is loss making and shut-downs are the most obvious potential catalyst. Another 100-150,000 tonnes per annum needs to be cut away, which UBS expects is more likely in the later stages of 2016 and into 2017.

The broker downgrades Western Areas ((WSA)) to Sell from Neutral, incorporating a recent placement and lower Australian dollar nickel price forecasts. The broker remains drawn to Independence Group ((IGO)) with development risks expected to fade once Nova commences production in 2017.

UBS downgrades Alumina Ltd ((AWC)) to Neutral from Buy, primarily to reflect a reduced valuation and recent share price movements. The broker believes the spot alumina price has recently shifted to reflect downside risk, as refinery re-starts occur in China.

Zinc and lead are Credit Suisse's top picks in the base metals segment, with supply shortfalls looming as mines close. Aluminium and alumina have recovered with the curtailment of supply in China but the broker suspects capacity is available to re-start which will limit the price rebound.

Iron Ore

Declining Australian shipments and improving steel producer fundamental underpin Macquarie's preference for iron ore exposure. Port data suggests that both Rio Tinto and BHP Billiton ((BHP)) will report a significant drop in shipments in the first quarter of 2016.

The broker notes evidence that iron ore supply has responded quickly to higher prices, with material volumes from Sierra Leone and India. Nevertheless, the broker is comfortable with its 2016 average US$50/t forecast, given improving steel mill fundamentals.

Moreover, the news that Arrium ((ARI)) has entered voluntary administration puts at risk 8.5-9.0mtpa of loss-making production. Macquarie maintains a preference for Fortescue Metals ((FMG)) and Rio Tinto.

Steel Margins

Margins have expanded substantially in China, Macquarie observes, as the steel mills benefit from a recovery in demand, assisted by seasonality, low steel inventory and slower rises in production. The broker also suspects the upside risk to Chinese growth forecasts is increasing.

Macquarie observes steel prices have disconnected from iron ore in recent weeks with steel rising 6.0% and iron ore falling 4.0%. The broker expects the margin improvement should be sustainable in the weeks ahead, but ultimately there is no reason for a sustainable, structural improvement in Chinese steel markets.

Mills will lift production beyond the pick up in demand by the middle of the year and margins will prove attractive which will enable more re-starts, a similar situation to what is occurring in aluminium, the broker maintains.


Find out why FNArena subscribers like the service so much: "Your Feedback (Thank You)" - Warning this story contains unashamedly positive feedback on the service provided.

article 3 months old

Rocky Road Ahead For Iluka Resources

-Downgrades to earnings estimates
-China's property market soft
-Question over dividend levels


By Eva Brocklehurst

Towards the end of last year, reports on the mineral sands industry signalled a weakening trend for prices. For 2016 so far this is being confirmed, with brokers observing a period of price stability could be nearing an end. This spells the start of a rocky road for Iluka Resources ((ILU)).

The company has matched its peers, conceding to a US$100/tonne reduction in zircon pricing for the June quarter. Tronox was the first to announce a price cut, followed by Rio Tinto ((RIO)). The three major players represent 65% of the market. Rio Tinto's action puzzled Deutsche Bank, considering zircon is but a small share of the company's diverse portfolio. The broker suspects Rio has decided to either sell down zircon inventory or wants to lift market share.

Whatever the reason, Iluka has been forced to follow suit and reduce its premium zircon price to US$950/t. Deutsche Bank lowers its average zircon price forecasts by 6.0% for 2016 and by 10% for 2017, suspecting there may be further risks to the downside.

The company has guided to 2016 production of 660,000 tonnes and suggested aggregate sales volumes – zircon/rutile/synthetic rutile - might exceed production. Yet, Iluka also expects a greater share of standard zircon sales in 2016 which, all up, suggests to brokers a lower realised price.

UBS draws this conclusion from lower transaction prices towards the end of the March quarter and its assessment of the weak demand-supply situation, pointing to the curtailing of Jacinth-Ambrosia for 18-24 months. Furthermore, UBS has lifted Australian dollar forecasts between 1-5% over 2016-20. Hence, the company's cash flow outlook is reduced and the stock is downgraded to Sell from Neutral.

How the cuts to zircon prices translate to average realised prices depends on a number of factors, Morgan Stanley maintains. Nevertheless, the price cut should equate to a 15% reduction in medium-term earnings, and reduce the broker's base case valuation by 6.0% if it carries over the longer term.

Credit Suisse also deduces from the company's comments that while combined production will be sustained, the composition may change in terms of lower zircon volumes. Incorporating changes to zircon prices and sales volumes means the broker downgrades revenue by 6.0% for FY16 and 7.0% for FY17. Profit estimates are downgraded 24% for FY16 and 23% for FY17.

Credit Suisse suspects it has a more downbeat view of China's property construction industry than consensus after the most recent TZMI report. The survey suggests demand could be down in single digit percentages in 2016 because of sluggish property clearance rates, weak margins and environmental pressures leading to the closure of smaller operators.

This signals lower demand for zircon, potentially. Industry feedback suggest new construction starts could be down 10% year on year, more than the broker previously expected, and it appears the mineral sands industry is starting to look like many other commodities, for prices need to push deep into the cost curve to bring about the necessary curtailment of supply. Hence, Credit Suisse suspects zircon prices may move sharply lower.

One aspect to the supply/demand balance Deutsche Bank observes is that while demand for zircon is improving slowly, new supply has entered the market from smaller producers. For these producers zircon is a by-product and a small revenue stream. Now the majors have cut prices, the broker suspects there might be further downside to pricing over 2016.

Macquarie expects the outlook for Iluka will be challenging, with a number of key decisions to be made, none the least of which is managing the current business in a weak market. Having failed to acquire Kenmare, the need to address a shortfall in sulphate ilmenite also presents a hurdle, along with the suspension of Jacinth-Aambrosia and falling future revenue from BHP Billiton ((BHP)) Mining area C.

Iluka may not be able to sustain its current dividend levels, Credit Suisse asserts. The company's policy is to pay out a minimum of 40% of free cash flow but given the current balance sheet and the fact it does not need the cash at this point, the broker has assumed a 100% pay-out of free cash flow through to FY19.

After adjusting for lower zircon prices this generates a dividend of 39c a share in FY16 but in FY17 this is considered likely to contract to 25c. Hence, Credit Suisse does not find valuation multiples nor the dividend yield compelling in 2017, even assuming a zircon price of US$975/t.

FNArena's database shows one Buy rating (Citi), one Hold (Morgan Stanley) and five Sell for Iluka Resources. The consensus target is $6.11, suggesting 9.2% upside to the last share price.
 

Find out why FNArena subscribers like the service so much: "Your Feedback (Thank You)" - Warning this story contains unashamedly positive feedback on the service provided.

article 3 months old

The Monday Report

By Greg Peel

Comeback

It was looking pretty ugly for the ASX200 at the open on Friday, with early falls suggesting we could be in for one of those pre-weekend capitulations as sentiment turned sour once more. But having opened down 70-odd points, the index very quickly found buying support.

The early drop took us down through 4900, which suggests the impetus to buy at that point was largely a technical one. Or we might simply note that every time the index has fallen through 5000 this year, and even down towards 4800, it has subsequently recovered to trade back over 5000 every time.

Outside of a 1.3% fall in the insignificant info tech sector on Friday, the banks and energy led the index to its close of down 26 with 0.8% falls. Thereafter, sector falls were lighter and fairly uniform, but for utilities which managed the only gain on the day, up 0.2%.

Sentiment this week will centre on the first of the US earnings results, along with the first quarterly reports from local stocks.

Bring it on

Janet Yellen appeared at a gathering of Fed chairs past and present after the close of US trading on Thursday evening. Joined by Volker, Greenspan and Bernanke, it was not really the forum for Yellen to be spouting any significant change of heart on current monetary policy. Not that she was likely to anyway, and she didn’t.

The yen pulled back against the US dollar ahead of the open on Wall Street on Friday after its surging run on Thursday. Prime Minister Abe had previously ruled out intervention but on Friday Japan’s finance minister said he may act against a “one-sided” yen.

The easing yen allowed the US stock markets to open with some strength, taking the Dow up 150 points in the first half hour as oil prices posted another 5% jump. On the 2016 correlation, it was a no brainer for a solid session in US stocks. But this month that correlation has broken down.

The Dow closed up 35 points or 0.2% while the S&P gained 0.3% to 2047 and the Nasdaq was flat.

Oil prices may be bouncing around a lot, but at the moment they’re not really getting anywhere. The lack of overall direction, despite day to day volatility, has meant stock traders have moved on to concentrate on other drivers. This week that means corporate earnings, which by some measures have been now forecast to fall as much as a net double digit percentage.

Forecasts have actually been getting weaker and weaker this past couple of weeks, which tends to suggest they have become a little overblown to the downside. The proof of the pudding awaits over the course of the next month. Alcoa reports tonight, then there’s a bit of a gap to week’s end when the big bank results start to flow. The pullback from the highs for the indices on Friday night, despite oil holding onto 5% gains, likely reflects squaring up ahead of the first earnings numbers.

Commodities

Last week’s US data showed a surprise drop in crude inventories. On Friday night, the Baker Hughes rig count showed a drop to 354 from 362 a week earlier and 760 a year ago. While the third straight week of lower rig counts was no great shock, the oil market is beginning to see the numbers lining up and moving in the right direction.

No one expects this weekend’s meeting in Doha to result in any meaningful supply freeze agreement between OPEC and non-OPEC members, but on last week’s US data it probably doesn’t matter that much anymore. There may yet be some disappointment if nothing eventuates in Doha, but on the wider scheme of things, earlier talk of WTI having to go back to test its US$26 low is now waning.

West Texas was up US$2.08 or 5.5% at US$39.61/bbl on Saturday morning and Brent was up US$2.26 or 5.7% at US$41.85/bbl.

Stronger oil prices provided incentive for a more positive session on the LME. Copper and zinc rose 0.5%, tin 1%, aluminium 1.5% and nickel 2%.

Iron ore fell US50c to US$53.30/t.

Gold was relatively steady at US$1238.40/oz.

The US dollar index fell 0.3% to 94.19, helping the Aussie to rise 0.6% to US$0.7551.

The SPI Overnight closed up 20 points or 0.4% on Saturday morning.

The Week Ahead

US earnings results will be closely watched at the beginning and end of this week. US date releases this week include retail sales, inventories, the PPI and Fed Beige Book on Wednesday, CPI on Thursday, and industrial production, fortnightly consumer sentiment and the Empire State activity index on Friday.

China will release its March quarter GDP result on Friday. Forecasts suggest 6.7% growth, down from 6.8% in December.

Ahead of that release, Chinese monthly inflation numbers are due today, trade on Wednesday, and industrial production, retail sales and fixed asset investment on Friday.

Housing finance numbers are due out in Australia today. Tomorrow sees the NAB monthly business confidence survey and Wednesday the Westpac consumer equivalent. The monthly jobs lottery takes place on Thursday and on Friday the RBA will release a Financial Stability Review.

On the local stock front, Energy Resources of Australia ((ERA)) is due to release its March quarter production report today, thus kicking off the resource sector quarterly production reports season. Fortescue Metals ((FMG)) reports on Wednesday and Whitehaven Coal ((WHC)) on Thursday while Rio Tinto Plc ((RIO)) will hold its London AGM on Thursday night.

The non-mining quarterly report/update/ investor day season will be kicked off by IOOF Holdings ((IFL)) on Wednesday followed by Bendigo & Adelaide Bank ((BEN)) and Transurban ((TCL)) on Thursday.

Rudi will first appear on Sky Business on Tuesday, via Skype-link around 11.15am, then again for two hours on Wednesday morning (10-midday), on Thursday he'll be back from 12.30-2.30pm and finally he'll do another linkup via Skype on Friday morning, probably around 11.05am.
 

For further global economic release dates and local company events please refer to the FNArena Calendar.

Find out why FNArena subscribers like the service so much: "Your Feedback (Thank You)" - Warning this story contains unashamedly positive feedback on the service provided. www.fnarena.com

article 3 months old

The Overnight Report: The Rising Problem

By Greg Peel

The Dow closed down 174 points or 1.0% while the S&P fell 1.2% to 2041 as the Nasdaq fell 1.5%.

Fail

The ASX200 did not make it back to 5000 yesterday, peaking out at midday at 4984 as momentum stalled. Having already jumped over 3% the day before on a turnaround in the oil price, the energy sector managed only a 1.4% gain despite oil prices being up 3% overnight.

The market appears not yet convinced there is any reason for a push above 5000 at this point. When that’s the case, the only other way is down. Last night Wall Street provided the incentive for a possible lower low to be established today on this most recent down-leg.

While news that Arrium had placed itself into voluntary administration was hardly a shock to the market yesterday, it does highlight the extent of the reversal of fortunes of Australia’s economy from the heady days of the China-driven “super-cycle”. Is the steel industry in Australia set to go the way of the car industry? BlueScope’s hanging in there, but unlike Arrium, BlueScope doesn’t mine iron ore. And it sells Colorbond rooves, not construction girders.

If Arrium goes under so does the town of Whyalla, and that means increased unemployment. Arrium can’t move the market anymore but it can impact on sentiment.

Only the telcos and consumer discretionary finished in the red yesterday. The banks managed a 0.3% gain but that might change today.

Watch the Yen

The Japanese yen is the world’s “safe haven” currency. This might seem strange given the Japanese economy has been in the doldrums for 25 years but it was Japan’s persistent deflation that long ago created the “yen carry trade” that has served to drive the value of risk assets globally ever since.

Given Japan’s ultra-low interest rates, which existed long before the GFC, investors can borrow in yen at next to nothing and invest in the likes of the US, Europe or Australia to receive an “arbitrage” return on the yield differential. This requires selling yen and buying the currency of the target assets. That “arbitrage” only works so long as yen exchange rates remain relatively stable. If global risk begins to increasingly worry carry trade investors, foreign assets are sold and yen loans repaid. The result is a rising yen. The yen thus appears to be a “safe haven” currency because whenever risk increases, the yen rises.

Last night the yen hit its highest level against the US dollar in almost 18 months. The yen’s rise has been exacerbated by weakness in the US dollar since the Fed started backing down on its rate rise plans. Wall Street had not been paying a lot of attention up to now but when last night the Japanese government said they would not intervene in the currency, the world took notice. The last time the yen hit this level the Bank of Japan shocked the world by announcing a massive expansion to its QE program. More recently the BoJ has cut its cash rate into the negative. Last night the BoJ confirmed it will “undertake additional monetary easing measures if necessary”.

Which opens up the prospect of the Japanese cash rate going even further into the negative. The issue here is the “race to the bottom” among central banks, each equally desperate to devalue their currencies so as to maintain export competitiveness. If Japan goes again, then Europe would likely have to follow, and China. The Fed would likely need to hold out on raising for longer.

Hence the US ten-year bond yield fell 6 basis points to 1.69% last night. The German equivalent fell to 0.09%. The German yield curve is negative almost up to ten years. How does a bank make money on loans if rates are negative that far out on the curve?

Well they don’t. Last night European banks came under renewed selling pressure. The German index closed down 1.0%. On Wall Street, the primary driver of last night’s fall was a hammering of the financial sector.

And that, of course, prompted renewed calls of “overdone” and “oversold” when it comes to the US banks. Outspoken JP Morgan CEO Jamie Dimon, for one, described his bank as so well capitalised it is a “fortress” that would remain standing even if every other bank in the country went under.

With oil prices coming off slightly last night after Wednesday night’s big rally, there was no oil correlation support provided to offset weakness in the hefty financials sector. Yet traders are not overly concerned. Most have been expecting a pullback following the sharp rebound rally off the mid-February lows. Some are even salivating at the prospect of cheaper entry prices ahead of the earnings season, which begins next week. Earnings expectations have been marked down so low as to suggest, as has so often been the case in past quarters, that upside surprise is almost inevitable.

Commodities

West Texas crude is down US20c at US$37.53/bbl and Brent is down US22c at US$39.59/bbl.

Constant talk of slowing global growth is not providing any incentive to buy base metals, outside of supply curtailments. Last night copper fell 3%. Zinc fell 2.5%, nickel 2% and aluminium 1%. Only tin bucked the trend.

Iron ore is unchanged at US$53.80/t.

Despite the soaring yen, counter-balancing moves in other currencies sees the US dollar index steady at 94.49. But the “safe haven” shift means gold is up US$18.00 at US$1240.30/oz.

Which developed economy has not recently joined in the “race to the bottom” among central banks, nor even adjusted to account for it? The Aussie is down 1.25% at US$0.9505.

Today

The SPI Overnight closed down 74 points or 1.0%.

Coincidently, Japan will release its February trade data today.

Locally, REITs Dexus Property ((DXS)) and Investa Office ((IOF)) will hold extraordinary shareholder meetings today to discuss the proposed takeover by Dexus of management of Investa’s portfolio.

Rudi will skype-link with Sky Business this morning, around 11.30am, to discuss broker calls.
 

All overnight and intraday prices, average prices, currency conversions and charts for stock indices, currencies, commodities, bonds, VIX and more available in the FNArena Cockpit.  Click here. (Subscribers can access prices in the Cockpit.)

(Readers should note that all commentary, observations, names and calculations are provided for informative and educational purposes only. Investors should always consult with their licensed investment advisor first, before making any decisions. All views expressed are the author's and not by association FNArena's - see disclaimer on the website)

All paying members at FNArena are being reminded they can set an email alert specifically for The Overnight Report. Go to Portfolio and Alerts in the Cockpit and tick the box in front of The Overnight Report. You will receive an email alert every time a new Overnight Report has been published on the website.

Find out why FNArena subscribers like the service so much: "Your Feedback (Thank You)" - Warning this story contains unashamedly positive feedback on the service provided. www.fnarena.com

article 3 months old

The Overnight Report: Oil Fights Back

By Greg Peel

The Dow closed up 112 points or 0.6% while the S&P rose 1.1% to 2066 as the Nasdaq jumped 1.7%.

Can’t buy it, can’t sell it

While the ASX200 keeps finding reasons of late not to push up sustainably beyond 5000 – perceived bank woes are a case in point most recently – it just doesn’t like being under 5000 for very long either. While it was a choppy session on Bridge Street yesterday as sellers and buyers battled it out, the buyers won out in the end without any real incentive to do so other than every time the index falls below 5000, it pretty soon recovers.

The energy sector was the exception yesterday, rising 3.2% because the oil price recovered from an initial fall on Tuesday night and closed slightly higher. Traders in oil stocks must by now have very stiff necks from whiplash as they stampede backwards and forwards on every one dollar move in the oil price, only to find themselves forever back where they started.

Beyond energy, there appeared to be some bargain hunting going on in the industrials, healthcare, materials and consumer discretionary stocks yesterday. The banks closed relatively steady, which at the moment is a good day for the banks, while telcos fell, having not fallen on Tuesday, and consumer staples saw minor selling.

Buyers of oil stocks will nevertheless be feeling chuffed this morning following another jump in oil prices overnight. The ASX200 closed 55 points shy of 5000 yesterday and will likely close some of that gap today. The overnight futures are calling 18 points up but then they were calling 18 points down yesterday morning, and we closed up 21. An outside bet on 5000 being recovered today is not a silly one.

Oil Shock

US crude inventories fell by 4.9m barrels last week. Analysts had predicted a 2.9m increase. I don’t ever recall analysts getting the weekly numbers spot on but this is a bit of boilover. For those who get a bit warm and fuzzy over stats, it is the biggest fall in crude inventories for this particular week of the year since 1997.

When WTI futures “closed” early in the afternoon, the benchmark oil price was up over 5%. The market doesn’t actually “close”, it simply switches to electronic trading and carries on non-stop from Monday morning to Saturday morning. A closing price is nevertheless marked for bookkeeping purposes. Since that mark WTI has come off a bit, to be up 3%.

The oil price rally pretty much turned around what had threatened to be a weak session. Wall Street was soggy on the open, in line with European trading which had been soggy for most of the day. After the shock fall in German manufacturing orders revealed on Tuesday night, last night saw German industrial production for February falling 0.5%. This actually wasn’t too bad a result given forecasts were for a 1.8% fall.

The minutes of the March Fed meeting were also scrutinised last night. While Yellen’s speech last week largely rendered these minutes redundant, what was interesting was a debate between FOMC members about whether April should see a rate rise. Those believing April is too soon apparently won out.

Now, Yellen has suggested that April remains “live”, meaning the Fed could still hike if it so decided, but then every meeting has to, by default, be deemed “live” or what’s the point holding it? What we saw in the minutes was a rather unusual discussion about the future rather than the moment, ie whether or not to raise in March, and despite Yellen’s speech implying even June is looking unlikely, the fact April can be taken off the table was at least enough incentive for traders to pile back into “risk” stocks last night.

The epitome of “risk” stocks are the US biotechs, and with risk you get “momentum” traders. So when biotechs began to move up last night, the bandwagon was jumped upon. That’s why the Nasdaq was up 1.7% when the Dow only managed 0.6%. The S&P split the difference.

It could just as easily completely reverse in a session or two. Yellen will speak again tomorrow morning Sydney time, after the close of Wall Street tonight.

So between oil and a “momo” rally, Wall Street had a positive session last night.

Commodities

We recall that producers within and without OPEC are planning to meet in Doha in a couple of weekends to discuss a production freeze. Last night the Kuwaiti oil minister expressed confidence that an agreement would be reached. This clown is probably cracking the champagne as we speak believing he managed to orchestrate a 5% oil price jump when all of OPEC knows a production freeze is complete fantasy.

Only supply curtailment in the US will move oil prices higher. Last night’s weekly US inventory drop is why oil prices are up.

West Texas is up US$1.21 or 3.3% at US$37.73/bbl and Brent is up US$1.47 or 3.8% at US$39.81/bbl.

Yet again there were mixed moves in base metals last night. No move exceeded one percent.

Iron ore fell US20c to US$53.80/t.

The US dollar index is down slightly to 94.50 but gold is also down US$8.90 at US$122.30/oz.

One presumes the 0.8% rally back for the Aussie overnight to US$0.7600 is oil-linked.

Today

The SPI Overnight closed up 18 points or 0.4%.

As noted, Yellen’s speech will begin after Wall Street closes tonight.

Before that, we’ll see the local construction PMI and Bank of Queensland ((BOQ)) will publish its first half result.

Rudi will make his weekly appearance on Sky Business, 12.30pm-2.30pm and re-appear again on Switzer TV between 7-8pm.
 

All overnight and intraday prices, average prices, currency conversions and charts for stock indices, currencies, commodities, bonds, VIX and more available in the FNArena Cockpit.  Click here. (Subscribers can access prices in the Cockpit.)

(Readers should note that all commentary, observations, names and calculations are provided for informative and educational purposes only. Investors should always consult with their licensed investment advisor first, before making any decisions. All views expressed are the author's and not by association FNArena's - see disclaimer on the website)

All paying members at FNArena are being reminded they can set an email alert specifically for The Overnight Report. Go to Portfolio and Alerts in the Cockpit and tick the box in front of The Overnight Report. You will receive an email alert every time a new Overnight Report has been published on the website.

Find out why FNArena subscribers like the service so much: "Your Feedback (Thank You)" - Warning this story contains unashamedly positive feedback on the service provided. www.fnarena.com

article 3 months old

The Overnight Report: Be On Your Lagarde

By Greg Peel

The Dow closed down 133 points or 0.8% while the S&P lost 1.0% to 2045 and the Nasdaq fell 1.0%.

Market Worries

“The Australian dollar has appreciated somewhat recently. In part, this reflects some increase in commodity prices, but monetary developments elsewhere in the world have also played a role. Under present circumstances, an appreciating exchange rate could complicate the adjustment under way in the economy.”

This is the critical paragraph from yesterday’s RBA monetary policy statement, with the rest of the statement remaining little changed from previous months. Glenn Stevens has acknowledged that while stronger commodity prices are a welcome driver of a stronger currency, the “race to the bottom” among Australia’s trading partners has left the local currency sitting out like a shag on a rock through no fault of its own.

A weaker Aussie is important to aiding the transition away from dependence on mining investment in the Australian economy, hence recent strength is “complicating” the issue. This could be the first signal the RBA is prepared to act from an exogenous perspective, simply to bring Australia into line with the rest of the world. We note that even New Zealand has bowed.

The Aussie initially rallied on yesterday’s statement release because there was no rate cut – not that anyone was expecting one. Only then did the forex cowboys actually read the statement, and in so doing realise it was actually dovish. The Aussie is down 0.8% over 24 hours at US$0.7541 despite the US dollar being steady.

Yesterday was not a day, nevertheless, in which any hope of an imminent rate cut was going to make any difference to sentiment. The writing was on the wall at the close on Monday, when an attempt to rally above the 5000 mark failed. Markets that fail to go up tend to go down instead. And we’ve seen this movie all too often now – once we fall through 5000, we pretty quickly get down to 4900 or 4800, before returning.

Consumer discretionary is one sector that does not like a weaker currency, which may go some way to explaining that sector’s 2.1% fall yesterday. Although I’d suggest there was a delayed response to Monday’s weak retail sales data in play as well.

The banks don’t like lower rates, but there’s a lot more going on in the banking world at present than this concern alone. A 3.3% fall in the energy sector yesterday reflected a lower oil price, and for the banks this means an increased threat of default on energy sector loans. But we also had APRA releasing its discussion paper on Net Stable Funding Ratios on Monday, which by yesterday had bank analysts suggesting the majors will need to raise billions more in debt funding in order to comply. Throw in APRA’s warning that the current lending scene is beginning to look a lot like 2007, and there’s plenty of reason the banks were down 1.4% yesterday.

Including ASIC’s accusation Westpac has been rigging the bank bill swap rate settlement.

Despite an unchanged iron ore price overnight and mixed metal price movements, the materials sector fell 1.5% yesterday. Perhaps the ongoing insistence of analysts that the recent commodity price rally has no substance on a supply-demand basis is weighing. Or perhaps yesterday was just another day to sell everything. Only the telcos came out almost unscathed.

Not helping the mood was the release of Australia’s service sector PMI. It fell into contraction in March at 49.5, down from 51.8 in February. The service sector is the Australian economy’s underlying growth engine. The services PMI result is in stark contrast to the manufacturing PMI which is showing frenetic expansion, but the service sector is many multiples larger than the manufacturing sector in this country.

Around the Grounds

Which is not the case in Germany. If it wasn’t bad enough last night that the eurozone’s services PMI disappointingly fell to 53.1 from 53.3, data showing a 1.2% fall in German manufacturing orders when a 0.2% gain was expected caused ripples across the continent.  The German stock index fell 2.6% last night, while France chimed in with a 2.2% fall and the UK 1.1%.

The UK services PMI showed a gain to 53.7 from 52.7 while Japan again disappointed with a drop to 50.0 from 51.2. The winner on the night was the US, which posted a welcome return to expansion with a rise to 51.8 from 49.5.

IMF chief Christine Lagarde last night warned that global growth was slowing. The IMF has a habit of telling everyone what they already knew some six months after they originally knew it. Lagarde also suggested that while fiscal policy needs to play its part, negative interest rates represent “net positives” for the global economy. This is not an opinion held by the majority of the market.

The impact of Lagarde’s comments was a fall in the German ten-year bond rate to 0.10%, dragging the US equivalent down 5 basis points to 1.73%. There is  now talk of the German rate going to zero or lower, and the US rate thus testing GFC lows of 1.3%.

Healthy Pullback?

Oil prices opened lower last night, which, combined with the weak data out of Germany and Lagarde’s warning ensured a weak open on Wall Street. Tax policy was also in play, with Pfizer pulling out of a multi-billion dollar bid for global peer Allergen now the US government has clamped down on the practice of tax “inversion” – acquiring an offshore based company in a lower company tax regime and shifting headquarters.

Wall Street now anticipates more such takeover bids will be abandoned and takeover premiums will evaporate. Interestingly it was another session in which Wall Street ultimately ignored the oil price. WTI had already begun to bottom out and turn around when news came through of an explosion at an Iraqi oil well. Oil prices closed higher on the session but the selling in US stocks accelerated towards the bell.

The stronger service sector PMI was lost in the wash. Like Australia, the US service sector is much bigger than the manufacturing sector.

Last night’s weakness did not seem to bother too many traders, however, a lot of whom have been expecting a pullback following the sharp rebound from the February lows. Arguably Wall Street is consolidated back to a more measured platform from which to assess earnings results, which start to flow next week.

Commodities

West Texas crude is up US$1.06 or 3% at US$36.52/bbl while Brent is up US83c or 2.2% at US$38.34.

Yet another mixed night of trading on the LME saw copper and lead steady, aluminium down 1%, tin down 1.5% and zinc down 2%, while nickel rose 1%. If these ongoing ups and downs were consistent across the base metals then fair enough, but the reality is each metal is more often going up one night and down the next.

Iron ore remains unchanged at US$54.00/t.

Gold has jumped US$15.90 to US$1231.20/oz. It’s nothing to do with the US dollar index, which is steady at 94.63. It no doubt has a lot to do with the head of the IMF being keen on negative cash rates.

Today

The local energy sector should in theory find support today from a bounce in the oil price. Otherwise the SPI Overnight closed down 18 points or 0.4%.

Caixin will publish its China service sector PMI today, not yesterday as I erroneously assumed, because of the holiday in China on Monday. Renewed focus on the strength or lack thereof of the European economy will centre on German industrial production numbers.

The minutes of the last Fed meeting will be published tonight but they have already been superseded by the Fed chair herself, and Yellen will speak again tomorrow night.
 

All overnight and intraday prices, average prices, currency conversions and charts for stock indices, currencies, commodities, bonds, VIX and more available in the FNArena Cockpit.  Click here. (Subscribers can access prices in the Cockpit.)

(Readers should note that all commentary, observations, names and calculations are provided for informative and educational purposes only. Investors should always consult with their licensed investment advisor first, before making any decisions. All views expressed are the author's and not by association FNArena's - see disclaimer on the website)

All paying members at FNArena are being reminded they can set an email alert specifically for The Overnight Report. Go to Portfolio and Alerts in the Cockpit and tick the box in front of The Overnight Report. You will receive an email alert every time a new Overnight Report has been published on the website.

Find out why FNArena subscribers like the service so much: "Your Feedback (Thank You)" - Warning this story contains unashamedly positive feedback on the service provided. www.fnarena.com

article 3 months old

Material Matters: Copper, Aluminium, Australian Resources And Steel & Scrap

-Demand growth still missing for copper
-Re-firing of aluminium capacity possible
-Macquarie: commodity backdrop improving
-Turnaround in steel & scrap looms

 

By Eva Brocklehurst

Copper

Morgan Stanley suggests an opportunistic transfer of copper metal to China has occurred and as a result copper is delivering mixed signals to the market. Ex China the market is increasingly bullish but inside China it is bearish.

Ultimately, the broker believes demand growth is still missing. Global copper has responded strongly to the change in China's credit conditions by delivering metal into the local market. For price stability to occur in 2016, stockpiles in China need to be drawn down along with sustained construction activity.

China is sitting on at least 3m tonnes, Morgan Stanley contends, which means there is a surplus. So, in order for prices to find support, demand needs to grow.

Morgan Stanley is in Chile next week for the copper conference. The issues are how much new projects can deliver and the source of future supply growth, as well as production cuts and mine costs. Overall, the broker envisages a balanced market for copper this year.

The inventory build-up in China is cause for concern but the broker suspects a seasonal pick-up in demand over April-May may prompt a draw on stocks. Moreover, copper's global inventories are far from excessive and any stalling on the supply side would tighten the market quickly, the broker contends. The biggest downside risk is another year of weaker-than-anticipated growth in China.

Aluminium

Supply-side discipline has stabilised the aluminium price, Morgan Stanley observes, a rare occurrence. Now weakening demand growth and China's credit surge are threatening price support. The broker observes almost 5.5mtpa of capacity was removed since 2014 while smelting costs have fallen 20-25% since 2011, versus a 30% price decline.

China's monthly aluminium exports have fallen in 2016, partly from reduced production and stabilising demand. However, while China's production rate fell from its mid 2015 highs, it was still up 10% year on year in January. Aluminium prices have also rallied 10% since the November 2015 low. This is boosting the appeal of re-firing capacity that is offline and threatens prices for the short term, the broker contends.

Australian Resources

Macquarie assesses the potential of a weaker US dollar on earnings forecasts. Mining equities have made inroads into costs over the past four years, aided by currency movements. Since mid 2011 when the Australian dollar peaked at US110c the currency has declined 30%. With currency tailwinds easing, the broker expects specific commodity exposure and operational performance to become more critical.

Marking to market, Macquarie reduces earnings forecasts, downgrading FY16 estimates for BHP Billiton ((BHP)), Rio Tinto ((RIO)), Fortescue Metals ((FMG)) and Newcrest Mining ((NCM)) by 14%, 1%, 3% and 5% respectively. Forecasts for South32 ((S32)) are upgraded 8%.

Macquarie maintains a mixed outlook for commodities for the next two years, expecting a decline in iron ore, thermal coal, manganese and aluminium. Material rises for oil, US gas, nickel, silver, zinc and lead are factored in which combine with expectations for a stronger US dollar.

In the first quarter of 2016 the best performer of the London Metal Exchange was tin, which made a gain of 16%, Macquarie observes, followed by zinc, up 12%. Copper added 3%. All three were down more than 5% in early January but made sharp recoveries in February/March.

Three metals were either flat - aluminium - or weaker - nickel down 3% and lead down 4%. These three acted in reverse, up early in the quarter and then fading by the end.

Macquarie observes iron ore was the strongest performer in the March quarter, gaining 24% and gold was not far behind, up 17%. Crude recovered after hitting a new low in mid February, ending the quarter up 6% for Brent and 3% for West Texas Intermediate. The broker considers this a remarkable turnaround and one that clearly helped the metals complex.

All up, the broker considers the strong performance of metals over the quarter as a sign that demand conditions and the economic backdrop are improving. A more mixed second quarter is expected.

Steel

A rally in steel and scrap prices in the past month has helped drive a recovery in equities, Credit Suisse notes. Australian names such as BlueScope Steel ((BSL)), Sims Metal Management ((SGM)) and Arrium ((ARI)) are up 7.7%, 23.6% and 32.4% respectively.

The broker highlights the potential for BlueScope's shares to rally further if recent spread improvements are maintained. An additional $150m in earnings could be generated at a $220/t spread assumption for 2m tonnes of sales, on the broker's modelling.

Sims' peer Schnitzer's second quarter results indicated significantly weaker export demand and non ferrous and ferrous sale prices falling to multi-year lows. The silver lining, in Credit Suisse's view, is that it appears to mark a turning point in the cycle for scrap merchants.

Price increases over March have led to a 1-% increase in volumes. Guidance from Sims in February was based on there being recovery in volumes or price, both of which have now occurred. This infers for Credit Suisse possible outperformance against guidance, or at least a materially improved FY17 for Sims.
 

Find out why FNArena subscribers like the service so much: "Your Feedback (Thank You)" - Warning this story contains unashamedly positive feedback on the service provided.

article 3 months old

The Overnight Report: Marking Time

By Greg Peel

The Dow closed down 55 points or 0.3% while the S&P lost 0.3% to 2066 and the Nasdaq fell 0.5%.

Devil in the data

The graph of yesterday’s trade in the ASX200 shows a near perfect arc, rising steadily to a peak of 47 points up around mid-session and then falling equally as steadily to a flat close. Once again it’s as if escape velocity was unable to be reached at the peak and the gravitational pull of 5000 was just too strong.

The stand-out sector move yesterday was in energy, which closed down 2.9% on a 4% overnight fall in oil prices. Despite a tick-up for iron ore and mixed base metal prices, materials closed down 0.8%. The only other sector to finish notably in the red was consumer discretionary, down 0.3%, which goes some way to explaining why early momentum was lost. The day’s economic data releases were not so flash.

Morning releases included February retail sales, which were flat on January despite forecasts of 0.4% growth. It appears economists underestimated a drop-off in demand in the mining states of WA and Queensland. Over the three months to February, sales rose 0.7%, compared to 1.0% in the previous three months. Over twelve months to February, sales rose 3.3%, down from 3.5% a year ago and below the 4.5% decade average.

Retail spending constitutes around 30% of household spending and around 17% of GDP, CBA’s economists note. The data thus provide a significant indicator of the health of the Australian economy. It is perhaps no surprise retail spending has cooled as housing growth has cooled.

Building approvals data released yesterday showed residential approval growth of 3.1% in February, down 9% over twelve months. Detached housing approvals fell 1% to be down 5.6%, so the balance came from apartment approvals which rose 7.7%.

That’s a decent clip for apartments, although approvals are down 12% year on year. We recall from last week’s data that investor loan growth is down 11% from its peak mid last year and apartment sales fell 11% in February. So one might say, good luck to those developers increasing apartment approvals by 7.7% in February. Let’s hope they’ve sold off the plan.

ANZ revealed yesterday job ads series grew by only 0.2% in March and have remained broadly unchanged in number since November last year. In trend terms, ads fell 0.2% in March, representing the first fall since October 2013.

It does not surprise ANZ’s economists given such a strong run last year, but jobs growth is clearly cooling.

Headline inflation was flat in March after falling 0.2% in February, according to the Melbourne Institute gauge. (Did we lose TD Securities somewhere along the way? I wasn’t told.) Annual inflation is running at 1.7%. Take out food and energy, and core inflation rose by only 0.8% in the March quarter.

Put all of the above together, and throw in an Aussie dollar at US$0.7605 (which is actually down a percent over 24 hours given those data), and it will be interesting to read what excuse Glenn Stevens comes up with today not to cut the cash rate when all about are cutting theirs, or in the Fed’s case, not raising.

Lacklustre

Oil prices were down another 3% overnight, which should be enough to explain weakness on Wall Street. That correlation is not as strong as it was previously but it’s still a factor.

We also had the Boston Fed president and FOMC member coming out last night to say that the Fed will probably raise its cash rate “sooner than the market expects”, which did appear to bump the indices down at the time, but given half the market is not even expecting a rate rise this year it’s hardly a significant statement.

US factory orders fell 1.7% in February. A lot of the fall was to do with a drop in lumpy aircraft orders but a 20% fall in oil and mining related equipment is more indicative of the current state of play.

Beyond that, it was a fairly light volume session on Wall Street last night showing no real conviction either way. Alcoa will report quarterly earnings next Monday night, unofficially kicking off the earnings season. Wall Street is now in a bit of a holding pattern.

Estimates have net earnings per share for the S&P500 falling 7% in the March quarter. A lot of that relates to the energy sector, where falls in excess of 100% (ie falling from profit into loss) are forecast. The focus will very much be on just how the non-energy industries fared.

Commodities

West Texas crude is down US$1.22 or 3.3% at US$35.46/bbl and Brent is down US$1.17 or 3.0% at US$37.51/bbl.

It was another mixed session on the LME last night. Zinc fell 0.5%, copper 1% and lead 2% while nickel rose 1%.

China was closed yesterday, thus iron ore is unchanged at US$54.00/t.

The US dollar index is flat at 94.57 but gold is down US$6.60 at US$1215.30/oz.

Today

The SPI Overnight closed up 2 points.

It’s service sector PMI day across the globe today, including in Australia. Caixin will represent China.

We will also see the local February trade numbers today ahead of this afternoon’s RBA rate decision, or lack thereof.

Rudi shall hook-up into Sky Business via Skype at around 11.15am to discuss broker calls.
 

All overnight and intraday prices, average prices, currency conversions and charts for stock indices, currencies, commodities, bonds, VIX and more available in the FNArena Cockpit.  Click here. (Subscribers can access prices in the Cockpit.)

(Readers should note that all commentary, observations, names and calculations are provided for informative and educational purposes only. Investors should always consult with their licensed investment advisor first, before making any decisions. All views expressed are the author's and not by association FNArena's - see disclaimer on the website)

All paying members at FNArena are being reminded they can set an email alert specifically for The Overnight Report. Go to Portfolio and Alerts in the Cockpit and tick the box in front of The Overnight Report. You will receive an email alert every time a new Overnight Report has been published on the website.

Find out why FNArena subscribers like the service so much: "Your Feedback (Thank You)" - Warning this story contains unashamedly positive feedback on the service provided. www.fnarena.com

article 3 months old

Better Funded Western Areas Dependent On Nickel Recovery

-March quarter cash burn surprises
-Flexibility to re-start mine development
-Supply shut down should reinvigorate price

 

By Eva Brocklehurst

Western Areas ((WSA)) offers an opportunity to leverage a recovery in the nickel price but the critical question is: when will this recovery occur?

In the meantime, the company has decided to shore up its balance sheet with a $60m placement to institutions and a further $10m envisaged from a share purchase plan. Western Areas will use the proceeds to make the final payment for the Cosmos acquisition earlier than scheduled at a discount, and for working capital.

Morgan Stanley expects a nickel price recovery. Excluding growth capital expenditure, a cash break-even nickel price of $5.20/lb is estimated. If current Australian dollar nickel prices persist the broker expects a net cash position will be maintained out to FY19.

Even under an aggressively lower nickel price, e.g. 15%, the broker believes the company will be net cash until the end of FY17. Such a fall in the nickel price is considered highly unlikely. After a 1.3% decline in global stainless steel production over 2015 the broker forecasts production to rise 2.4% over 2016.

Why is nickel a top commodity pick? Morgan Stanley observes minimal supply cuts ex China over 2015 and nickel is trading deepest within its industry cost curve, exhibiting the least amount of supply rationalisation.

Demand is now stabilising and there is an increasing number of significant supply curtailments, with possibly more to come, which should tip the market balance into deficit. On this theme, Morgan Stanley maintains Western Areas offers leverage to a nickel price recovery.

Now, with a larger buffer in the balance sheet and a reduced risk profile, the company also has the means to withstand any delay in this recovery, and the broker acknowledges a recovery may be challenged by elevated inventory levels. Morgan Stanley's base case puts the nickel price at US$5.38/lb in FY17 and averaging US$8.40/lb in the long term.

Bell Potter was already of the view that Western Areas was sufficiently well funded to manage decade-low nickel prices, but the company indicated its net cash position deteriorated sharply as a result of a continued decline in the Australian dollar nickel price and cash outflows.

Hence, the broker believes the company needs to deliver lower operating costs to retain a robust financial position. Bell Potter's investment thesis is predicated on Western Areas being a low-risk, pure nickel exposures. The broker, not one of the eight monitored daily on the FNArena database, retains a Buy rating and $2.70 target.

Deutsche Bank agrees that without deeper cost reductions the company will continue to burn cash if the Australian dollar nickel price does not rally. The broker was surprised by the cash burn in the March quarter which placed the balance sheet under pressure. Moreover, Deutsche Bank cannot as yet envisage a clear path to the cost reductions that are needed beyond June 2016, when vertical mine development will need to re-start at Spotted Quoll.

Free cash flow is expected to remain negative at spot prices for the foreseeable future. The broker estimates Western Areas could burn $20m per annum at spot prices of US$3.80/lb and a US76c Australian dollar rate. A nickel price of US$4.20/lb is needed, the broker suggests, to break even. This falls to US$4.00/lb if exploration and studies are suspended.

While sustaining capital is low, the company is of a view that a low level of capital expenditure can be maintained for 1-2 years. Should nickel prices lift the funds raised will provide flexibility to accelerate mine development again, UBS contends, envisaging the funds adequate for two years before cash balances tighten again.

The nickel price is not considered sustainable at current levels over the long term. Assuming the placement is completed at the floor price of $1.95, the broker's FY17 earnings per share estimates dilutes 18%.

Credit Suisse would prefer a rights issue to a placement, so all shareholders may participate and avoid valuation dilution. Nevertheless, it makes sense to the broker to raise the money and continue with growth initiatives, because supply shut-downs are nigh and this should lead to a recovery in the nickel price.

FNArena's database shows three Buy ratings, two Hold and two Sell. The consensus target is $2.34, suggesting 14.3% upside to the last share price. Targets range from $1.80 (Ord Minnett) to $2.90 (Morgan Stanley).
 

Find out why FNArena subscribers like the service so much: "Your Feedback (Thank You)" - Warning this story contains unashamedly positive feedback on the service provided.