-Gold main beneficiary from Brexit
-Zinc and tin stand out in base metals
-Demand growing but not strongly
-Supply being rationed
-But not enough to push up prices
By Eva Brocklehurst
Strategy and Outlook
Commonwealth Bank analysts suggest, as another disappointing year passes for mining and energy companies, that FY17 is shaping up for further falls in commodity prices, albeit not as severe. The analysts expect the slowing of China's commodity-intensive sectors will continue as government stimulus fades.
Construction, which accounts for 40% of China's steel demand, is the most important end-user demand segment and late last year, the analysts observe, property construction volumes were falling materially in year-on-year terms.
Lower production costs and rising US interest rates should also apply downward pressure to commodity prices. Some miners view the recovery in commodity prices as sustainable and this suggests supply will be more reluctant to exit the industry. Yet if the recovery is not sustainable, which the CBA analysts believe is the case, this behaviour will weigh on prices.
The analysts anticipate oil prices will lift modestly as the market appears to be re-balancing. Gold and other precious metals also look more promising. Among the base metals the analysts consider zinc to be the stand-out commodity, given mounting concerns about a deficit as London Metal Exchange inventories head lower.
The decision by the UK to leave the EU has created all sorts of fears, the analysts maintain. Commodity demand waxes and wanes with economic growth so the impact will be about the extent to which global economic growth slows.
Metals generally feel the affect of swings because their demand is most elastic, with energy somewhat less so and agriculture less so again. At this stage investors and currencies have felt the most impact, the analysts maintain.
They also suggest, for the most part, fundamentals will remain foremost in commodity markets. In terms of Brexit, the primary impact should be felt through a stronger US dollar, safe haven demand and falling commodity consumption in Europe. One effect that may be material is any disruption to global trade flows of goods and commodities.
The depth, maturity and liquidity of different commodity markets are also relevant. Copper, gold and oil may be prone to volatility. Equally, developing markets for coking and thermal coal and iron ore may be relatively immune, the analysts believe.
In aggregate, this suggests gold will perform the best. While other commodities are less appealing the analysts believe coal and oil are likely to outperform and nickel and aluminium to underperform. Iron ore could fare worse because of its strong inverse relationship with the US dollar.
In essence, the analysts believe the consequences of Brexit will emerge slowly and caution itself, as much as sentiment delays spending decisions, may be the biggest issue for commodity market for the rest of 2016.
Macquarie observes, overall, commodities have performed better than feared at the start of 2016. Much of the sequential price increases can be attributed to changes in China but the broker believes the industrial recovery is a global phenomenon. While the recovery remains modest, especially in comparison to how the sector was performing before the GFC, this is a positive development for commodity demand.
The broker notes headwinds for both metals and bulk commodities, such as US dollar strength and oil prices, have eased in the year to date and this will help to stall the multi-year cost deflation cycle moving into the second half of the year.
Macquarie agrees zinc has been the most conspicuous performer among the base metals this year but, half on half, tin was actually stronger and remains the only base metal up year on year in terms of its June average price. The broker struggles to find catalysts to move copper out of its current range but agrees the long-awaited deficit for nickel is finally emerging.
The main surprise in the six months to June has been stronger bulk prices. Macquarie has raised its 2016 demand forecasts across most commodities but does not expect this to be strong enough to create bottlenecks.
Given excess capacity in all markets, and with interest rates set to stay lower for longer, pricing is expected to be at a level where supply is suitably rationed. The broker expects gains in price are most likely to be a result of a cost-push from rising oil prices, with the exception of zinc.
One of the big themes in 2015 was the rebalancing of markets via a reduction in production, Morgan Stanley observes. These announcements declined sharply in the first quarter of 2016 and improved demand growth has meant some markets have tightened sufficiently to support prices. The broker cites zinc, iron ore and coal in this regard.
Nickel appears to be an exception as its supply-side response to the price fall in 2015 was quite modest, Morgan Stanley observes. The broker believes, with the nickel price still below half of the cost curve and inventories high at exchanges, more production closures are likely.
Recovering prices pose a new risk too, the broker maintains. This is the risk of operations restarting. This is most acute for alumina/aluminium where large operations which were closed late last year and early this year in China are now being re-opened. Estimates suggest around 500,000 tonnes per annum of aluminium smelting capacity was re-started in the first half and should lift in the second half.
The broker also notes the price upside for zinc is capped by the potential of a full return of Glencore's 500,000tpa, apparently removed from the market in October 2015. Re-starts elsewhere are considered unlikely as a seasonally quieter season looms for iron ore, copper and nickel.
Find out why FNArena subscribers like the service so much: "Your Feedback (Thank You)" - Warning this story contains unashamedly positive feedback on the service provided.