- NAB, Goldman Sachs revise commodity price forecasts
- Gold a particular beneficiary
- Chinese iron ore purchases expected to increase short-term
- Solid underlying Chinese demand to underpin metal prices
By Chris Shaw
For the March quarter, National Australia Bank's Non-Rural Commodity Price Index rose 11.2% in US dollar terms, which equated to a 9.3% increase in Australian dollar terms. For the year to December 2010 the index rose a total of 51.7% in US dollar terms.
In the March quarter price movements were not uniform, NAB Australia and commodities economist Ben Westmore noting oil prices rose on the back of MENA conflicts, which at the same time raised concerns cost pressures will impact on industrial metal demand. Base metal prices fell in March by 3.2%, while gold rose by a similar percentage amount during the month.
With conflicts spreading across a number of regions and with global economic uncertainty still a factor, Westmore suggests it is no great surprise precious metals have seen support given their safe haven status.
Looking ahead, Westmore notes recent trends in PMI or Purchasing Managers Index readings across a number of countries are supportive of demand for those commodities used in the production process. The PMI increases point to signs of a broadening economic recovery.
Less positive for commodities is the gradual emergence of inflationary pressures, Westmore noting this has the potential to impact on physical demand. This doesn't change Westmore's view non-rural commodity prices should remain elevated through 2011, though some moderation in bulk commodity prices is expected as supply constraints ease.
Westmore expects the NAB Non-Rural Commodity Price Index will grow by around 24% to the end of December, before an easing in prices in 2012 as additional supply comes on line in response to recent high prices.
Looking at specific sectors, Westmore suggests about US$15 of the recent gains in oil prices can be ascribed to unrest in MENA countries, the rest of the increase being attributed to strong macroeconomic data from the US and the core Euro area.
With the mood in the MENA region remaining tense there continues to be scope for a supply shock in oil, but Westmore notes there have been indications Saudi Arabia is willing to lift production as a counter measure if such a supply shock was to eventuate.
Westmore has lifted his oil price forecasts, with an average price forecast for Brent crude for 2011 of close to US$115 per barrel now, up from US$93 per barrel previously. Prices are expected to average around US$110 per barrel in 2012.
If the MENA conflict was to become broader-based, Westmore notes there would be scope for prices to rise significantly higher. On the other side of the ledger, if Libyan capacity was to soon be restored, downside risk to the oil price would likely be limited by the gradual gains in global demand in recent months.
While prices among the base metals fell in March, Westmore notes price levels remain higher than they were at the end of 2010 in monthly average terms. Improving PMIs are a positive indicator for metal demand, even though Chinese demand for base metals has been somewhat subdued in the early months of 2011.
This reflects ongoing policy tightening as Chinese authorities attempt to deal with signs of increases in inflation. This has seen some easing in speculative investment demand, especially in copper. Copper stocks remain comparatively low, while nickel stocks are still historically high and aluminium stocks are most inflated relative to long-run average levels.
In coming months Westmore expects base metal supply will increase in response to recent strong demand and high prices. Excluding copper, Westmore expects supply will outstrip demand for all metals over the next two years.
This leads to a forecast of a 9% rise in the bank's Base Metals Index through the year to December, before a fall of around 4% in 2012. Westmore doesn't expect higher oil prices will have a significant impact on base metal demand.
Strong investor demand continues to support gold prices, Westmore seeing this as a reflection of continued safe haven buying on the back of the MENA conflicts, the broadening scope of sovereign debt concerns and uncertainty relating to the earthquake and tsunami in Japan.
Demand for gold has also been boosted by weakness in the US dollar and rising inflationary pressures, especially in the developing world. Westmore notes data from the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission showed net-long positions of non-commercial traders have declined in recent months, though this is being offset somewhat by an apparent rise in central bank demand.
Factoring in current conditions, Westmore has lifted gold price forecasts. He now expects prices to average around US$1,450 per ounce in quarterly terms through September, then a gradual easing beyond that time to levels of around US$1,375 per ounce by the end of 2012.
For the bulk commodities, support year-to-date has come from strong global steel production and some supply side constraints stemming from adverse weather conditions in major producing markets. While the Japanese disaster will cut demand short-term, Westmore expects reconstruction will result in stronger steel production. This in turn will mean solid demand for iron ore and coking coal.
Westmore anticipates a significant rise in new bulk commodity supply in both 2011 and 2012, which should broadly keep pace with growth in demand from emerging economies. This leads Westmore to suggest while prices for bulks should ease thanks to weaker demand growth in the developed world, prices are likely to remain at elevated levels.
Forecasts for iron ore stand at US$170 per tonne for the June quarter and US$150 per tonne for the December quarter this year and through the June quarter of next year. In hard coking coal, Westmore is forecasting average quarterly prices of US$295 per tonne in the June quarter, then US$280 per tonne for the balance of 2011 and US$270 per tonne by June next year.
For semi-soft coking coal Westmore is forecasting average prices of US$225 per tonne for the June quarter, then US$212 per tonne through the end of 2011 and US$205 per tonne through June next year. Westmore's forecasts for thermal coal stand at US$130 per tonne from the June quarter through March next year before an easing to US$110 per tonne in the June quarter of next year.
China will remain a driving influence on commodity prices and here NAB expects economic growth of around 9% in 2011, with some upside risk given a stronger than expected March quarter outcome. The forecast allows for further tightening in monetary policy in coming months.
National Bank has not been the only one to revise commodity forecasts, Goldman Sachs also seeing need to update estimates to mark-to-market price movements in recent weeks. The changes mean small downgrades for copper, platinum, palladium and uranium and upgrades for aluminium, alumina, lead, nickel and zinc.
The magnitude of the changes among the base metals is modest, as for example forecasts for copper for 2011 have fallen to US460c per pound from US466c previously while nickel forecasts have risen to US1,031c per pound from US1,001c previously.
More significant changes to Goldman Sachs' forecasts have come in gold, where the forecast for 2011 has been lifted to US$1,449 per ounce from US$1,348 previously. A similar increase comes in 2012, the new forecast of US$1,522 per ounce well above the previous estimate of US$1,383.
Gold prices continue to be supported by uncertainty in currency markets, geopolitical concerns and central bank buying. This sees the metal remain on Goldman Sachs' list of preferred commodities, as these factors imply price risk remains to the upside.
To play gold via listed Australian equities Goldman Sachs prefers Newcrest ((NCM)), Kingsgate Consolidated ((KCN)) and St Barbara ((SBM)), all of which are rated as Buys. The market agrees on Newcrest given a Sentiment Indicator rating according to the FNArena database of 0.9, well above the 0.4 reading for Kingsgate and 0.0 for St Barbara.
Turning to the bulks, while Goldman Sachs has not adjusted forecasts for the sector, Macquarie continues to see scope for a further short-term push up in prices in iron ore in particular. This is based on the view supply is tight relative to demand.
Macquarie expects a new round of Chinese iron ore purchasing activity in coming weeks, something that should support a move higher in prices. Whether this lasts into the second half of 2011 remains a question, Macquarie pointing out seasonal factors, the current credit squeeze and power shortages all threaten demand.
While any reduction in real demand could allow iron ore prices to trade below the range seen so far this year, Macquarie suggests any downside will be limited by an increase in cost support to around US$150 per tonne.
This should offer a higher level of support than was seen last year when prices bottomed at around US$120 per tonne.
Still on China, Macquarie notes power rationing has been introduced earlier than usual this year in response to higher prices for thermal coal and tight electricity supply. The power cuts are expected to hurt Chinese metals output, this at a time when demand conditions remain robust.
With thermal coal prices continuing to rally, Macquarie expects the Chinese will return to the seaborne market in coming months. This should support prices in that market, especially for low-CV Indonesian and off-spec Australian material.
Chinese metal demand for the March quarter was fairly solid in Macquarie's view, as consumption growth in year-on-year terms remained positive for most metals. There has been a further shift to greater raw material imports, Macquarie attributing this to the availability of downstream capacity and a push to add value within China.
While aluminium output fell during the period, Macquarie notes Chinese stainless steel production surged in the March quarter and lead and copper output recorded double-digit growth in year-on-year terms.
Net raw material imports fell in metals where there simply wasn't material available or where prices had run beyond a level at which Chinese buyers were comfortable. Macquarie suggests steel scrap and copper concentrate were examples of this during the period.
In summary, Macquarie suggests Chinese demand for commodities has held up well in the face of tightening measures. This suggests while metal prices will continue to react to macroeconomic news, underlying Chinese demand should underpin prices in the near future.